Just a heads-up before you read this, this letter is a long one, and it contains some deeply intrusive thoughts. There have been a few triggers lately that stirred up a lot of noise in my mind, and writing this has become the only real outlet I have to release some of that weight.
I know some of what I share here may be hard to read, but I hope you understand it’s not meant to blame or accuse, it’s just me trying to make sense of everything going on in my head and heart.
If there’s anything in here that I’m misinterpreting or don’t fully understand, I really hope you’ll talk with me about it. I want us to keep growing in openness and trust, even when the topics are difficult.
I’m writing this letter on the day we’re picking up your new car, a day I know is going to be really special for you. That’s why I’ve decided not to give this to you today. I want you to enjoy this moment without any extra weight on your heart.
To be honest, I don’t even know if I’ll ever give this to you. I’ve written others before, and some of them never made it into your hands. I ended up destroying them, not because they didn’t matter, but because they carried pieces of me I wasn’t sure I was ready to share.
This letter is long, probably the longest yet, because my mind has been running so fast lately. The thoughts are piling up quicker than I can make sense of them, and writing them down is the only way I know to keep from being overwhelmed. This is me, trying to breathe through the noise, trying to find clarity in the chaos.
The weekend trip to the river was a good one, peaceful in its own way and full of little moments I’ll remember. But truthfully, I think it’s something I’d enjoy more if it were just the two of us. That kind of environment isn’t quite right. So for now, I don’t plan on taking him back anytime soon.
I also came to realize something about Matt, he’s a friend best experienced in small doses. A couple of hours here and there is one thing, but a full weekend? That’s a bit too much. I guess it’s one of those things you learn by living through it. What I truly wanted from that weekend was time to relax and connect with you. That’s where I find peace.
Knowing how close you and KH are still weighs heavily on my heart. Even though you’ve told me that you don’t share everything with him, deep down, I can’t shake the feeling that you might be sharing parts of these letters, my most vulnerable, raw moments, as conversation points with him, maybe even with a hint of humor. I don’t know why I feel that way exactly, but it’s there, sitting in my gut like a quiet warning I can’t ignore.
What hurts the most is this sense that he knows more about what’s going on in your heart, mind, and in our life together, than I do. And I’m living it with you. I’m the one beside you every day, yet I feel like a stranger in some parts of your emotional world. That’s not easy to admit. I tend to be a very private person, and the thought of someone I barely know having insight into parts of me I haven’t even fully unpacked with you yet, it makes me want to pull away. It makes me feel like I need to protect my thoughts, not just from the world, but from being shared without context or care.
I understand you’ve known KH for a long time, longer than you’ve known me. And I’m not trying to erase that part of your life. But what’s hard for me is knowing he wasn’t just a friend, he is an ex-boyfriend. That changes the dynamic. You once told me that friends don’t kiss friends, and you and KH were more than that. That sticks with me. I know you’ve told me parts of the story, but I can’t help feeling like there’s more that you haven’t said, maybe because you’re afraid of how I’ll react, especially as we continue to move forward and grow stronger together.
One of my deepest fears is losing you, and sometimes, I can’t help but feel like KH is your exit plan if things between us were ever to fall apart. I’m not proud to admit that, but it’s the truth that’s been echoing in my mind since everything came to light.
When I saw the messages between you and KH, it felt like I’d been punched in the chest. It felt like betrayal, like I’d stepped into the same nightmare I lived through with Vickie. I know this situation is different, and I know you are not her, but that pain, that sting of broken trust, felt all too familiar. It brought back that old, paralyzing question I thought I’d left behind: What did I do wrong? Was I not enough? Am I just a placeholder until something, or someone, you once loved becomes possible again?
The hardest part in all of this wasn’t just the messages. It was realizing that the person you turn to most, the one you confide in the deepest, may not be me. And that leaves a kind of emptiness that’s difficult to put into words. When trust cracks, everything else begins to feel uncertain. And the thought of losing you to someone who already knows so much about your heart, that terrifies me.
I’m still here. I still love you more than I can express. But I need you to know how much this has shaken me, not because I doubt your love, but because I’m scared to lose something that means everything to me.
When the messages and the depth of your relationship with KH came to light, it hit me harder than I ever expected. It made me realize just how deeply I love you, how much you truly mean to me. But at the same time, it brought a painful thought to the surface, what if you’re still in love with someone else?
You are my world. And having that world shaken by broken trust, by things that were kept from me, is something I’m still trying to recover from. Right now, it feels like I’m carrying this weight alone. I find myself questioning things I wish I didn’t have to.
More than anything, I need to know that you truly love me. That you’re here with your whole heart. You know what I went through with Vickie, how I discovered the dishonesty only after she was gone. I know you’re not her. I don’t confuse who you are with who she was. But I can’t deny that the similarities in the situation, the secrecy, the messages, stir up those old wounds in me. The time when you were going through your messages looking for another “bomb shell” you still skipped over a lot things that were there. Things that were said that you never wanted me to know.
Even little things linger in my mind. Like the pet names. He called you “Gumball,” and when I asked, you wouldn’t tell me what you called him. And maybe it’s something small, but it adds to that feeling that there are pieces of the story still hidden from me. And all I want is honesty, openness, and reassurance that I’m the person you’ve chosen with your whole heart.
When we first met and spent that time together at the hotel, something happened between us. But not long after, we both shared that it felt a bit like we were cheating on our late spouses. At the time, I thought it was just part of the grief and transition, but after everything that’s come to light, I can’t help but wonder if, for you, it was different.
Looking back now, I think those feelings you had might have stemmed from being emotionally involved with KH. It makes me feel like I stepped into the middle of something that hadn’t fully ended. Seeing the messages you exchanged with him, so personal, so emotionally charged, makes me question whether I was unknowingly intruding on something still active between the two of you.
And then there’s the part I can’t ignore, the photos that were deleted. That kind of haunts me. Why were you so upset when I had open your photos on your Mac? You asked what I was doing and I was looking for photos of us. Is there some in a folder of you and KH that you did not want me to see? Makes me wonder, what was in those images that couldn’t be seen? What was too painful, too intimate, or too revealing?
I’m just trying to make sense of everything. These questions keep looping in my mind, and all I really want is some way to quiet the noise so I can feel grounded in this wonderful life we’re building together.
You told him in messages, just shortly after we started our relationship, that he was playing mind games with you, that you were building a life with me, yet you were secretly still in love with him. Reading that, it cut deeper than I ever expected anything could. It still echoes in my heart and weighs heavily on my soul.
What I continue to struggle with is why you never told me about the true nature of your relationship with him. I was led to believe he was just a friend, but those messages painted a much different picture, one I wasn’t prepared for. I remember you once said that, you don’t always get to choose your friends, and I’ve done my best to honor that with you. I’ve tried not to question who you choose to keep in your life. And I will never tell you who you can or cannot be friends with.
You told him you wanted to send photos of yourself in your new jacket, and even more intimate ones, of your legs, and up your dress. You mentioned how you liked the feeling of your legs wrapped around him. Those words are burned into my memory. They weren’t just casual, they were intimate, deeply personal.
I’m trying to process it all without resentment, but I’d be lying if I said it wasn’t tearing at something inside of me. I just need to understand how we move forward with trust, when the past feels so close and unresolved.
Looking back on some of the messages from the early days of our relationship, I can’t help but feel that you were genuinely in love with him at one point, and part of me wonders if a piece of that still lingers. It sometimes feels like you’re still carrying thoughts of him, wondering what could have been.
I’ve thought about how you asked him multiple times to move to Texas and be with you, and even after we were together, there were several times you asked if you could go see him, trips that never included me. A cruise for his birthday to celebrate, plans to go to Las Vegas, those didn’t seem just casual mentions. They felt personal, like you were trying to keep that door open. And it makes me question, were those just friendly gestures, or was there a part of you still searching for something in him, trying to see if the spark was still there?
I find myself wondering, if you had followed through on any of those trips, would we even be where we are today? Would we have had a chance at building this life together? And deep down, I can’t stop asking, why did you choose me over him? Have you really moved on? Because some of the messages where you professed your love for him were from just two years ago, and that closeness still haunts me.
When I was moving clothes from the Temple house to the Belton house, I came across that shirt you have of KH’s. Deep down, I can’t shake the feeling that it holds some kind of significance. You’ve kept it for nearly four years, and when I asked you about it, you said you didn’t remember how you got it. Maybe it’s just the cracks in trust talking, but I’m not entirely sure I believe that. It feels like there’s a story behind it, one you might not want to tell me. And that uncertainty weighs on me.
It also made me think of something else, another piece of clothing. That pink shirt with the heart on it. I remember reading one of your messages to him where you asked if he noticed anything about it. Is that something he gave you? Is there something special about it that I don’t know? These questions don’t come from a place of wanting to accuse, but from a place of wanting to understand, because right now, it feels like there are still pieces you do not want me to ever know.
I’m still trying to find a way to let go of all these emotions surrounding you and KH. I know you’ve explained why it was kept a secret, and maybe on some level I do understand, but not fully. And truthfully, I’m not sure I ever will. The fact that it was hidden from me for so long has left this lingering sense of unease. It’s like a shadow that won’t quite fade, no matter how much light we bring into our relationship.
It also stirs up painful memories I thought I had buried. After Vickie passed, I discovered she had been cheating on me, something I only realized by reading through her Facebook messages. That betrayal still echoes in me. And after seeing some of the conversations you had with KH, it triggers that same sense of heartbreak. The feelings are eerily familiar, that sinking pit in my stomach, that spinning confusion in my chest. I know you aren’t her, and I know this is a different situation, but emotionally, it touches the same raw nerve.
I don’t want to carry these thoughts forever. But they are here, and they’re heavy. And I’m just doing my best to work through them, piece by piece.
Nothing I do seems to quiet the deep hurt I’m carrying. These feelings just keep resurfacing, like an echo I can’t silence, this constant noise in my head that’s slowly wearing me down. And every time it happens, it feels like I’m reliving the pain all over again. It’s not always loud, but it’s persistent, like a low hum of uneasiness that there’s still something I don’t know, something you haven’t told me.
When we’re laughing or simply enjoying each other, the noise fades and I feel peace. But then, like clockwork, something reminds me, and the noise rushes back in. Sometimes it’s not even anything tangible, just a passing thought, and suddenly I’m spiraling. I remember a time when I thought he and I might even become friends. But now I realize why that never felt quite right.
It’s only now becoming clear to me why you were uneasy when I added him to that group chat, why his reaction to you, calling it a power move. That phrase has stuck with me. It felt like he was acknowledging something that I wasn’t even aware of at that moment. And maybe that’s what this is all about, that feeling of being the outsider in something I didn’t even know existed.
So how do I make these thoughts stop? I wish I knew. Even now, when I see you messaging him, I get this uncomfortable, almost sick feeling in my gut. It’s not just the fact that you talk, it’s that it often happens when I’m not around. That’s what makes it feel secretive, even if it’s not meant to be. I brought it up to you, and you laughed it off, saying it was just because you wanted to talk with me instead.
But that didn’t take the feeling away. Yesterday was the first time I remember you actually having a phone conversation with him while I was nearby, and even then, something felt off. You got really quiet during parts of it, like you didn’t want me to hear what was being said. It made me wonder: Did you tell him you couldn’t really talk because I was there? Was there something being said that you didn’t want me to hear?
You told me you talked to him while we were at the river, but why did you have to leave the campsite to do it? Why not just make the call where we all were, like it was no big deal?
These are the things that replay in my mind, and I wish they didn’t. I want to feel secure. But these moments plant doubt, and that doubt grows louder every time the silence sets in.
Please don’t take any of this as me not wanting you to be friends with him, that’s truly not the case. I know you and KH were there for each other during incredibly difficult times, and friendships built in those moments can be powerful and rare. I respect that. Friends like that aren’t easy to find.
I guess part of my struggle is rooted in comparison. When I look at your friendship with Amy, it’s clear she often makes things about herself and isn’t always there for you the way you deserve. But with KH, it’s different, he was there. I see that, and I honor the space that relationship holds for you.
Right now, I feel so alone in all of this, even though I know I’m not truly alone. It’s just this overwhelming weight that’s hard to describe. There are moments where I want to disappear, to escape from everything. I’m starting to feel numb, and that scares me, because I know what that numbness can become. I can feel the early edges of depression creeping in, and I’m trying so hard to push through it.
What keeps me grounded, what keeps me holding on, is the life we’re building together, the love that exists between us. That love is real, and it’s the anchor I cling to when everything else feels unstable. But I’d be lying if I said I never feel like I’m walking this emotional road alone. I love you with everything I have, and all I want is to feel that love going both ways, not just in words, but in presence, in trust, and in emotional closeness. I don’t want to be the person in a relationship who loves deeply but quietly wonders if they’re loving alone.
Just know that no matter what I’m going through, no matter what storms are swirling in my head, my love for you remains unwavering. I love you with every ounce of my being, fully, fiercely, and without hesitation. I know I tend to overthink, and I’m sorry for the weight that sometimes brings into our world. It’s never meant to cause pain, it’s simply my heart trying to protect what it cherishes most, you. I’m looking forward to all the years ahead with you, to building a life filled with love, laughter, and healing. I can’t wait to grow old with you and call you my wife.